RSJ Faculty Blog

Sunday, August 20, 2006

Sparks political reporter's blog raises ethical questions

Sparks Tribune political reporter Tom Darby writes a personal political blog that involves many of the subjects he covers for the daily paper.

This was brought to my attention by the person who writes the Nevada blog, Dullard Mush. While the Dullard Mush writer feels that Darby's two forums reflect a conflict of interest and are downright unethical, I maintained that reporters are entitled to their opinions along with the freedom to express them. Because Darby is being open about his opinions, he's allowing readers the kind of insight that will better allow them to sift his newspaper reports and decide for themselves what perspectives or biases might have impacted the reporting process.

Transparency is a good thing, right?

RGJ reporters Anjeanette Damon and Ray Hagar also write a blog, "Inside Nevada Politics," though it runs on the newspaper's Web site and is clearly under the RG-J's editorial control.

24 Comments:

  • On my Blog I'm asking who will take the White House in 2008? What do you think? who's your favourite? http://lukejyoung.blogspot.com/2006/08/america-decides-08-who-will-win.html

    please join in

    By Blogger Luke young, at 3:21 PM  

  • I believe blogs such as Darby’s are problematic though somewhat helpful at the same time.

    Blogging in itself is fine. The content of Darby’s blog is in stark conflict with what should be his professional ethics.

    News professionals have obligations to the profession as well as rights as individuals but must make a value judgment about which one takes precedence and then be consistent in practice.

    Masquerading as an actual political reporter in print while directly advocating for and against political candidates on a blog is basically dishonest in my view.

    The somewhat helpful aspect here is that those readers who go to Darby’s blog, do indeed get a clear picture of his political thinking. They also will see, for instance, that his writing is sloppy and that he resorts to name-calling. Both of these may help readers reach conclusions about the quality of his reporting. That helps.

    Some would say he is more honest than other reporters because he’s is not lying about what he thinks. It’s all there on his blog. Well, that’s not enough for me. It’s incomplete and assumes that all readers are able and willing to check out the blog.

    Ah, this could be very good - expecting that readers can be responsible for some checking things out. Yes, I like it. But we’re not there yet. That’s not how journalism works for the most part - not yet. It still rests on the article of faith (flimsy perhaps) that journalists are primarily committed to providing factual, supported, even-handed reporting and are not unduly influenced by political agendas. (I don’t claim that pure objectivity exists, just that trying for it has its place here.)

    Yes, transparency is a good thing when it’s complete, instantly accessible and universal. I don’t think it’s being transparent to say one thing in one place and another somewhere else essentially leaving it to the audience to figure it out. Transparency is upfront, constant and across the board. Let’s say for example that – at the least - all journalists should preface every article with a statement of political and religious beliefs. That might be a start.

    Also, I believe the putative honesty of the blog is outweighed by his readiness to ignore the professional norms of journalism. These norms may be flawed and incomplete but until better ones are universally accepted and understood, Darby is not free to ignore them if he wants to present himself as a journalist.

    I see him as a pretender cashing in on what little credibility the profession has by holding a job as a reporter while he really wishes to push an agenda.

    I prefer to see Darby respect the conventions of the profession and bow out as a reporter. He is an advocate for a political view and should be an opinion writer. In fact, the ST should make that decision for him. The situation is more damaging to the paper and the profession than it is to Darby.

    RMcCarthy

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:03 PM  

  • Thank you Diedre for taking the time to examine this and post it here for discussion.

    I agree with McCarthy that it reflects more poorly on the Tribune than Darby. While the paper may not be bothered by his endorsement of candidates on his blog, I'd like to think his tactics of giving a "heads up" to political friends regarding possible legal action and posting an email a disgruntled candidate wrote his editor would.

    As McCarthy noted, and Diedre has mentioned as well, knowing how Darby's mind works and where his biases are is helpful in decoding (perhaps) his daily stories in the Tribune.

    But, in my case, the only reason I stumbled upon it was that a "Thomas Darby" had posted a comment on my blog grumbling that I had mentioned the RGJ and that there were two other papers in town, one of which he worked for. When I then read of a reporter threatening someone and saying he was "a Constitutionalist" it was fairly easy to connect the two. But how many of the Tribune's readers would know this?

    By Blogger The Anon Guy, at 7:56 PM  

  • I'm going to be wishy-washy.

    On the one hand, the appearance of a conflict of interest can be as -- er -- interesting as an actual conflict of interest.

    To avoid this perception, mainstream reporters have been traditionally encouraged to avoid being perceived as taking sides on almost any issue.

    Many of the best business reporters, for example, will not own stocks or bonds. These reporters don't want it to appear that their financial stories might be influenced by some sort of self-interest.

    I must say, I respect these reporters' integrity. And when I read their stories, I trust them.

    But, on the other hand, I can't see how anybody can ever be totally unbiased. A blog post might provide a hint about what's going on inside a reporter's brain. And it might serve as a sort of self-disclosure statement.

    A problem, as Anon Guy points out, is that the folks who read a certain newspaper are often not the same folks who read a specific blog. So blogs my not provide the full disclosure that some might desire.

    Hmmmm ...

    -- Larry D.

    By Blogger LarryD, at 12:05 PM  

  • I'm trying to think through the issues presented by this dilemma.

    Is it a problem that a political reporter has a blog that allows investigative readers to discern his personal preferences? Would it be better if he didn't have a blog so we wouldn't know his views?

    Or, is the problem that not enough readers have access to the blog to be able to filter his point of view, as some posters implied? If that is the case, then disclosure in the paper would help solve that problem.

    Or is it a problem that the newspaper is employing someone who is a political activist in the off hours while working a day job that requires full and balanced consideration of all political points of view? News reporters are expected to be balanced and fair in covering issues.

    Is Darby's reporting in the Sparks Tribune balanced? Fair? Does he provide readers with a full account of the various political stories he covers? Would a range of readers with different perspectives agree that his stories are illuminating and useful to the community? If not, then the problem isn't whether he is publishing a blog, but how he is doing his day job.

    Perhaps the concern is that a hidden agenda is distorting the balanced perspective we expect to find in most newspapers. The blog doesn't seem to be the most relevant issue in this question. The blog simply publicizes what the reporter is already thinking and doing.

    Do the readers think his reporting is sound? Does his editor? If not, that should be the issue. If his reporting does hold up, then the blog doesn't seem to be a problem.

    Or...is the issue one of perception as opposed to reality? Perhaps we are in such a state of partisan division that we need to maintain a facade of objectivity to have any hope of maintaining credibility. We can't accept even the appearance of partisanship on the part of anyone who wants to report news.

    On the third hand, perhaps this facade is what drives the public away from our work. They don't want partisans parading as independent minded thinkers and they don't believe that it is possible for anyone not to have private passions. A catch-22?

    By Blogger donica, at 4:25 PM  

  • I'm still thinking about Rosemary's comment: "Let’s say for example that – at the least - all journalists should preface every article with a statement of political and religious beliefs. That might be a start."

    Perhaps a return to the partisan press--where one knows what a publication stands for--is a solution. The media universe will neatly divide into Nevada Blue and the Pack Patriot with their predictable partisan content.
    I find it reassuring to know that The Economist is more likely to write articles praising welfare reform and that the NY Times might show the human face of a woman who's struggling because she can't find a steady job and her benefits were cut off. But still I read both publications.

    For most people, I suspect press partisanship aids the selective media exposure habits of the shallow minded, a problem that's already dividing the planet.
    The success of democracy depends on some shared set of knowledge or fact set--a story we have in common, something we can all agree on.

    That said, at the paper for which I write a column, we wear our politics on our sleeves deliberately. To say, "This is who I am and this is how I see things," feels far more honest than to try and give a story balance by quoting the specious facts and miscontrued allegations of the "other side." (My own facts never being specious or miscontrued, of course ...)

    A fair-minded reporter may never be tempted to make those arcane choices (leads, quotes, sources) that push one agenda over another. But the he-said, she-said structure of "objective" news stories, coupled with overworked underpaid reporters, can make for an awful lot of misinformation in the media.

    About a year ago, I interviewed Eugenie Scott, director of the National Center for Science Education, for a story on intelligent design.

    Her comments on the movement to "balance" evolution with its "alternatives" in an educational setting were applicable, I think, to the objective journalism debate.

    Scott explained: "Ask the average person on the street, 'Should we be teaching strengths and weaknesses of evolution?' They're going to say sure. Ask them, 'Should we teach the strengths and weaknesses of heliocentrism?' And they'll say sure."

    But ask a scientist about the "strengths and weaknesses of heliocentrism"--the theory that the Earth revolves around the Sun--and you'll get a blank stare.
    There aren't any alternatives to the Earth going around the Sun. Ask a biologist about the strengths and weaknesses of evolution, and you'll get that same blank look."

    My conclusion is, as always, that we need to start teaching media literacy in kindergarten if not sooner. If a kid is old enough to sing along with The Little Mermaid, she needs to know a bit about Disney Co. Today, kids, we're going to talk about vertical integration ...

    By Blogger Deidre, at 5:50 PM  

  • I received an email from the editor of the Sparks Tribune saying as of Monday blogs by staff are banned.

    Darby's site went dark that afternoon.

    There was no comment regarding why or what Tribune standards or codes had been violated (if any). From the tone of the email, I got the distinct feeling she thought it was simply some blog war and not an ethics issue.

    By Blogger The Anon Guy, at 6:12 PM  

  • By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:47 PM  

  • By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:08 PM  

  • Hi all!
    [url=http://yeshuanet.com/chat/chat/temp/index.html]britney[/url]

    G'night

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:49 AM  

  • "I have been using Advanced Gain Pro for 3 months now and I must say I'm simply amazed. I really didn't think the product would have this many benefits. I really only purchased the pills to help the reliability of my erections. But to my surprise every aspect of my penis and sex life has improved. I have larger, harder erections easily, and I can really satisfy my girlfriend fully now."
    Dexter, Chicago

    Finally! A new pill that really works!

    ________________________________
    Our others products, more info here:
    Ultra Allure Pheromones
    Anatrim

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:24 PM  

  • [url=http://www1.fccj.edu/wlara/jaxsearch/_kbas/000001eb.htm]Buy Ultram Online[/url]

    http://www1.fccj.edu/wlara/jaxsearch/_kbas/000001eb.htm

    Buy Ultram Online

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:21 PM  

  • Hello, very nice site! Please also visit my homepages:

    buy hoodia diet pills


    best diet loss pill weight


    See you soon!

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2:28 AM  

  • Hi,
    I found your blog via google by accident and have to admit that youve a really interesting blog :-)
    Just saved your feed in my reader, have a nice day :)

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:03 PM  

  • [URL=http://web-cam-girl-658sf4.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-girl-658sf4.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-girl-658sf4.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-girl-658sf4.sex-cam-live-chat-web.info/]web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-girl-658sf4.sex-chat-live-cam-nude.info/]web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-girl-658sf4.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.sex-cam-live-chat-web.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.sex-chat-live-cam-nude.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-658sf4.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.sex-cam-live-chat-web.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.sex-chat-live-cam-nude.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-658sf4.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]free web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.sex-cam-live-chat-web.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.sex-chat-live-cam-nude.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-sex-658sf4.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]web cam sex[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-chat-658sf4.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]web cam chat[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-chat-658sf4.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]web cam chat[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-chat-658sf4.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]web cam chat[/URL]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:05 AM  

  • [url=http://clipurl.com/?NZQ217]Play Online Games[/url], [url=http://clipurl.com/?YMT154]Play Games Free Online[/url], [url=http://clipurl.com/?GPA446]Boggle Game - Free Download[/url], [url=http://clipurl.com/?DNO771]Top 10 Websites for War Games[/url],
    [url=http://clipurl.com/?BVS628]Play Puzzle Games Free Online[/url]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:16 PM  

  • Hi!
    I like your story.
    But you'd better take a look here to find a really DIFFERENT dating site.
    Looks amazing, agree? :-)
    You can also find my pics and more about me on my page www.livedatesearch.com/jessica
    Read more about me or drop me a message from there.
    Chao!
    Jessica

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:50 AM  

  • http://dtmurl.com/9ry Aciphex
    [url=http://dtmurl.com/9ry]Aciphex[/url]
    Acipex
    ============================================
    http://kisaweb.com/phb Bentyl
    [url=http://kisaweb.com/phb]Bentyl[/url]
    Bentyl
    ++++++++++++++++++++++
    http://z.la/pngm7 Detrol
    [url=http://z.la/pngm7]Detrol[/url]
    Detroll
    *****************************************************
    http://www.mcturl.com/?r=3430 Nexium
    [url=http://www.mcturl.com/?r=3430]Nexium[/url]
    Nexium
    :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
    http://shrinkurl.us/nkX Prevacid
    [url=http://shrinkurl.us/nkX]Prevacid[/url]
    Prevacid
    Thx

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:28 AM  

  • [URL=http://live-web-cam-677f1.sex-chat-live-cam-nude.info/]live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-web-cam-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-web-cam-girl-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free live web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-girl-677f1.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]live web cam girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-sex-web-cam-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live sex web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-sex-web-cam-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free live sex web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-adult-web-cam-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live adult web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-web-cam-chat-677f1.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]free live web cam chat[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-free-personal-web-cam-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live free personal web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-chat-677f1.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]live web cam chat[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-nude-web-cam-677f1.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]live nude web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-nude-web-cam-677f1.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]free live nude web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-adult-web-cam-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free live adult web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://web-cam-live-chat-girl-677f1.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]web cam live chat girl[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-gay-live-web-cam-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free gay live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-personal-web-cam-677f1.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]live personal web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-teen-web-cam-677f1.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]live teen web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-web-cam-porn-677f1.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]free live web cam porn[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-feed-girl-cam-web-677f1.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]live feed girl cam web[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-animal-web-cam-677f1.sex-chat-live-cam-nude.info/]live animal web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-lesbian-web-cam-677f1.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]free live lesbian web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-gay-web-cam-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live gay web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-web-cam-babe-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free live web cam babe[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-web-cam-show-677f1.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]free live web cam show[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-porn-web-cam-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live porn web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://jasmin-live-web-cam-677f1.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]jasmin live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-live-xxx-web-cam-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]free live xxx web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-xxx-web-cam-677f1.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]live xxx web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-home-web-cam-677f1.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]live home web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-new-york-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live web cam new york[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-chat-rooms-677f1.live-chat-cam-sex.info/]live web cam chat rooms[/URL]
    [URL=http://jasmine-live-web-cam-677f1.live-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]jasmine live web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://creative-web-cam-live-ultra-677f1.sex-cam-live-chat-web.info/]creative web cam live ultra[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-amateur-web-cam-677f1.adult-cam-chat-sex.info/]live amateur web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-web-cam-woman-677f1.sex-cam-live-chat-web.info/]live web cam woman[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-adult-web-cam-chat-677f1.ive-sex-cam-nude-chat.info/]live adult web cam chat[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-sexy-web-cam-677f1.adult-chat-sex-cam.info/]live sexy web cam[/URL]
    [URL=http://free-web-cam-live-chatting-677f1.live-nude-cam-chat.info/]free web cam live chatting[/URL]
    [URL=http://live-wildlife-web-cam-677f1.sex-chat-porn-cam.info/]live wildlife web cam[/URL]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 4:20 PM  

  • [url=http://designerhandbag.skracaj.pl]Designer handbag[/url], [url=http://louisvuitton.skracaj.pl]Louis vuitton[/url], [url=http://designerpurse.skracaj.pl/]Designer purse[/url],
    [url=http://piercing.skracaj.pl]Piercing[/url], [url=http://bodypiercing.skracaj.pl]Body piercing[/url], [url=http://bodyjewelry.skracaj.pl/]Body Jewelry[/url]

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:52 PM  

  • By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:22 PM  

  • salute!
    Nice work!
    Very much interesting site. Here a lot of helpful information.

    Also visit my sites:

    [url=http://xenical.butkel1.org/]xenical[/url] http://xenical.butkel1.org/ xenical
    [url=http://hydrocodone.butkel1.org/]hydrocodone[/url] http://hydrocodone.butkel1.org/ hydrocodone
    [url=http://celexa.butkel1.org/]celexa[/url] http://celexa.butkel1.org/ celexa
    [url=http://ephedra.butkel1.org/]ephedra[/url] http://ephedra.butkel1.org/ ephedra
    [url=http://lorcet.butkel1.org/]lorcet[/url] http://lorcet.butkel1.org/ lorcet
    [url=http://meridia.butkel1.org/]meridia[/url] http://meridia.butkel1.org/ meridia
    [url=http://tramadol.butkel1.org/]tramadol[/url] http://tramadol.butkel1.org/ tramadol
    [url=http://carisoprodol.butkel1.org/]carisoprodol[/url] http://carisoprodol.butkel1.org/ carisoprodol
    [url=http://cialis.butkel1.org/]cialis[/url] http://cialis.butkel1.org/ cialis
    [url=http://paxil.butkel1.org/]paxil[/url] http://paxil.butkel1.org/ paxil
    [url=http://clonazepam.butkel1.org]clonazepam [/url] http://clonazepam.butkel1.org clonazepam
    [url=http://lortab.butkel1.org]lortab[/url] http://lortab.butkel1.org lortab
    [url=http://lexapro.butkel1.org]lexapro[/url] http://lexapro.butkel1.org lexapro
    [url=http://codeine.butkel1.org]codeine[/url] http://codeine.butkel1.org codeine
    [url=http://viagra.butkel1.org]viagra[/url] http://viagra.butkel1.org viagra
    [url=http://vicodin.butkel1.org]vicodin[/url] http://vicodin.butkel1.org vicodin
    [url=http://percocet.butkel1.org]percocet[/url] http://percocet.butkel1.org percocet
    [url=http://ativan.butkel1.org]ativan[/url] http://ativan.butkel1.org ativan
    [url=http://oxycontin.butkel1.org]oxycontin[/url] http://oxycontin.butkel1.org oxycontin
    [url=http://rivotril.butkel1.org]rivotril[/url] http://rivotril.butkel1.org rivotril


    Ciao!

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:43 AM  

  • http://www.adquity.com

    Classifieds for our community. Buy, sell, trade, date, events... post anything. Adquity Classifieds.

    http://www.adquity.com

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:50 AM  

  • By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:15 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home